Guy Pearce

Bender

DeWanda Wise

Sarah

Bill Pullman

Ross

Raoul Max Trujillo

Shakespeare

Ryan de Quintal

Hershel

Emily Katherine Ford

The Girl

Jack Alcott

Edward

Charlie Talbert

Cotton

Joanna Cassidy

Maggie

Josh McDermitt

Keith Jardine

Gibson

Andrew J. West

Sheriff Legsplint

Jamie Neumann

Whitey

Gail Cronauer

Miss Atwater

Teagan Ireland

Annie

Jimmy E. Jones

Satchel

Courtney Taylor

Narrator(as Courtney Taylor)

Chris Oatway

Bell Man

Joe Coughlan

Chicken Man

Bill Peters

Drunk

Matt Artisan

Deputy 2

Ike Shehadeh

Deputy 1

Jacob Woodworth

Patron 2

Nathan Woodworth

Patron 1

Hannah Mosqueda

Rocking Woman

David S. Lee

Ross's Confidant(as David Lee)

Thomas Wingate

Willard

James Cady

Proprietor(as James Louis Cady)

Teagan Ireland

Annie