Natalie Peri

Desire / Witch

Julie Anne Prescott

Char

Will Collazo Jr.

Ari Carson

Heather Harlow

Bridgette Heckel

Melissa Heflin

Good Mel / Bad Mel / Anne

Erica Dyer

Grace

Tina Krause

Nancy (archive footage)

Clint Beaver

Carl Steel

Kyle Rappaport

Joffrey

Jennie Russo

George Stover

Mr. Carson

Jamie Morgan

Lisa Avery

David Perry

Stuart Lincoln

Warren Dean Fulton

Seth

Rouge Rose

Emily

Marvin Maddicks Jr.

Marvin

Steven Haar

Theo Konvitz

Rudy Ledbetter

Rudy Ledbetter

Christopher Korek

Entity

Tim Hatch

Will Oaks

Ronnie Nanos

Ronnie

Edward Haynes Jr.

Ed

Noellie Burger

Sophia Flemmich

Thomas Antalek

Scruffy Duffy

Les Nolan

Les

Kellen DeRuy

Rusty Parr

Thomas J. O'Brien

Brad Stamper

Steven Kiseleski

Kenneth Keith Kallenbach

Eric Norcross

Tony Andrews

Jen Elyse Feldy

Sara Taylor

Brett Clark

Brett

Matt Skinner

Father

Josh Kelley

Ashtray Jones

HB Gibson

Hatch

Paul "Duck" Tucker

Randall Cheeks

Forrest Bennett

Jeff Senese

Mark Flemmich

Mark Flemmich

Bill Dawson

Griffin Graves / DJ Johnny Slacks

Rachel Max

Tricia Lee

Brannan Durham

Brannan

Jeffery Woods

Hy Pyke

Andy J. Davis

Ranger Mason

Charlie Skinner-Cheverie

Charlie

Mark C. Fullhardt

Dark Priest

Shawn Ness

Nathan Nix (voice)

Dan Romano

Theo

Valerie Strong

Valerie

James Janso

Ivan

Bobby F. Murphy

Todd Henrickson

Francis Erdman

Cult Member

Stephen Bloodworth

Rory

John Henderson

John

Cody Tudor

Cody

Marc Chindemi

Stanos

Mike Redman

Mike

Shannon Hall

Survivalist

John Ward

Cult Leader